Sweny’s Godfrey Run

Locally grown produce, cozy country charm, and ice cream right off the road.

📍 Where it’s at

Sweny’s Godfrey Run Farm is located in Lake City, just a short drive west of Erie. The address for your GPS is 9000 West Lake Rd, Lake City, PA 16423. You’ll spot it along Route 5. There’s a big white sign outside, you can’t miss it!

Open hours are: Monday-Wednesday 10 a.m.-7 p.m., Thursday-Saturday 9 a.m.-7 p.m., and Sunday 9 a.m.-5 p.m., plenty of time to stop by after work or enjoy a summer morning or evening!

Sweny’s Godfrey Run is now under new ownership by the Sweny family, and they’ve brought fresh energy and exciting upgrades to this classic local spot. Inside, you’ll find a beautiful sign with a thoughtful tribute to the previous owner—a heartfelt touch that shows just how much this place means to the community. There’s easy parking, and the whole place feels like a little slice of countryside tradition.

Advertisements

🍓 What’s good

@wandererie814

Amazing place for ice cream, fresh fruit, wine, and more! Sweny’s Godfrey Run in Lake City, PA! #erie #eriepa #814 #lakecity #lakecitypa #countryroads #eriecounty #icecream #fruitstand #grandopening

♬ Summertime – Kenny Chesney

They also have a bar where you can currently purchase local wine, with craft beer and cider selections coming soon. They also plan to offer seasonal specialty drinks that highlight the season and fresh fruits they’re selling in store, making the menu just as local and fresh as the produce. What makes this bar extra special? You can order from a window if your sitting outside! What a cool, special touch that we’ve never seen at a place like this.

Sweny’s Godfrey Run is a special little market with big ambitions. Their grand opening was phenomenal, and we can’t wait to come back for one of their upcoming live music events. Be sure to follow them on social media!

From January through April, they also hope to make the venue available for private event rentals (timeline to be finalized). So if you stop by and love the place as much as we do, maybe you can host your next event here!

👨‍👩‍👧 Who it’s good for

Families who want to enjoy a simple, fun farm stop with ice cream and fresh produce

Locals stocking up on seasonal goodsRoad trippers driving Route 5 or following the Lake Erie Wine Trail

Wine lovers interested in sampling local wines while browsing farm goods

Anyone looking for old-fashioned charm and quality food

Advertisements

🌾 Final thoughts

Sweny’s Godfrey Run is more than a farm stand—it’s an Erie County gem. Whether you’re after a crisp local apple, a scoop of ice cream on a hot day, or just a peaceful roadside stop, this little red barn delivers.

Looking for more family-friendly farm stops, ice cream stands, and seasonal markets? Check out more, right here, on wandererie.com!

Niagara Creamery

📍 Where it’s at

Tucked at 804 E. 38th Street, Niagara Creamery is a bright little shop in a residential Erie neighborhood. It’s owned by the local Paris family and was named after Erie’s famous Brig Niagara—it feels like Erie pride in every scoop niagaracreamery.com. There’s street parking nearby, and while it’s not on the beaten tourist path, it’s worth seeking out.


Advertisements

🍦 What’s good

This is hard-packed, small-batch ice cream made right here in Erie—with a menu full of fun options:

  • Scoops in crispy waffle cones, or go for gluten-free sugar or cake cones—they’ve got it all.
  • Sundaes, slush puppies, floats, and milkshakes—plus ice cream sandwiches rolled in your choice of toppings.
  • Try the flagship flurry, a thick blend of ice cream and candy—so thick, they joke, “you’ll need to bring your own spoon!”
  • They also offer non-dairy flavors, making it accessible for more folks.
  • Favorite flavors spotted lately include Blue Moon, Butter Pecan, Black Raspberry Cheesecake, and Banana Pudding.

Customers rave about the friendly service, fair prices, and generous portions—TripAdvisor gives them a top rating in Erie.


👨‍👩‍👧 Who it’s good for

  • Families of all ages, including those with dietary needs
  • Ice cream lovers looking for local flavor and variety
  • Gluten-free eaters (they do cones!)
  • Groups and parties—they also offer catering for events

🌤️ Final thoughts

If you’re craving locally made ice cream and a warm smile in Erie, Niagara Creamery hits the spot. It’s charming, thoughtfully inclusive, and irresistibly delicious. And bonus: perfect for summer road trip pit stops or post-beach treats.

Advertisements