📍 Where it’s at
Tucked at 804 E. 38th Street, Niagara Creamery is a bright little shop in a residential Erie neighborhood. It’s owned by the local Paris family and was named after Erie’s famous Brig Niagara—it feels like Erie pride in every scoop niagaracreamery.com. There’s street parking nearby, and while it’s not on the beaten tourist path, it’s worth seeking out.
🍦 What’s good
This is hard-packed, small-batch ice cream made right here in Erie—with a menu full of fun options:
- Scoops in crispy waffle cones, or go for gluten-free sugar or cake cones—they’ve got it all.
- Sundaes, slush puppies, floats, and milkshakes—plus ice cream sandwiches rolled in your choice of toppings.
- Try the flagship flurry, a thick blend of ice cream and candy—so thick, they joke, “you’ll need to bring your own spoon!”
- They also offer non-dairy flavors, making it accessible for more folks.
- Favorite flavors spotted lately include Blue Moon, Butter Pecan, Black Raspberry Cheesecake, and Banana Pudding.
Customers rave about the friendly service, fair prices, and generous portions—TripAdvisor gives them a top rating in Erie.
👨👩👧 Who it’s good for
- Families of all ages, including those with dietary needs
- Ice cream lovers looking for local flavor and variety
- Gluten-free eaters (they do cones!)
- Groups and parties—they also offer catering for events
🌤️ Final thoughts
If you’re craving locally made ice cream and a warm smile in Erie, Niagara Creamery hits the spot. It’s charming, thoughtfully inclusive, and irresistibly delicious. And bonus: perfect for summer road trip pit stops or post-beach treats.
Wander Erie 